Controversy over hormone replacement therapy:
Estrogen replacement therapy (ERT), the use of estrogen to supplement
that which is no longer being produced by the body, and hormone replacement
therapy (HRT), in which estrogen and progestin (a synthetic progesterone)
are used in combination, have been the subject of great controversy over
the years. And, because there is a risk versus benefit ratio in the supplementation
or replacement of these hormones, the debate still continues. In addition,
the high doses of estrogen therapy given when ERT began being used 50
years ago, gave hormone replacement therapy a bad reputation.
Today, the debate still continues and the choice to continue HRT if a
woman has already started or to start HRT as a woman enters perimenopause
and menopause is more controversial than ever. During the summer of 2002,
the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NHLBI) halted a major clinical
trial of the risks and benefits of combined estrogen and progestin in
healthy menopausal women, due to findings of an increased risk of invasive
breast cancer among its participants. The trial also found increases in
risk of coronary heart disease, stroke, and pulmonary embolism. The study
was scheduled to run until 2005.
The National Women’s Health Information Center (NWHIC), Office
of Women’s Health, US Department of Health and Human Services, in
response, offers the following suggestions for women who are currently
taking hormone replacement therapy:
-
The most important thing a woman can do in deciding to continue
hormone replacement therapy is discuss the current research with her
physician and healthcare team.
-
Women need to be aware that taking a combined progesterone and
estrogen regimen is no longer recommended to prevent heart disease.
A woman should discuss other alternatives of protecting the heart
with her physician.
-
Women should discuss with their physicians the value of taking
combined progesterone and estrogen replacement therapy to prevent
osteoporosis. There may be alternative treatments based on a woman's
unique health profile.
-
Women need to understand that this latest research does not affect
women who have had their uterus removed by hysterectomy, who are usually
prescribed estrogen alone. Those findings are not yet available.
Always consult your physician for more information.
What is hormone replacement therapy?
When a woman reaches menopause, the production of estrogen and progesterone
decreases significantly. HRT is a means of replacing these hormones that
are no longer being produced by the body. This type of therapy is usually
commenced at menopause or may be started while a woman is in the perimenopausal
phase, nearing menopause. In years past, many physicians would recommend
that women take HRT for the rest of their lives to realize the maximum
benefits; however, in light of the most current research, HRT is not advised
for all women. It is crucial that the decision to take HRT be made on
an individual based after a complete review of a woman’s medical
history.
How is hormone therapy replacement administered?
According to the American Medical Association, HRT can be administered
in a variety of methods, including the following:
| estrogen
pills |
Estrogen pills can
either be taken every day or for 25 days each month. Women who have
had a hysterectomy can take estrogen alone, while those who have not
may take a combination pill (estrogen and progestin). |
| estrogen/progestin
pills |
There are two methods
- the continuous method and the cyclic method - for taking estrogen
and progestin. In the continuous method, a pill that contains both
estrogen and progestin is taken daily. Occasionally, irregular bleeding
may occur.
The cyclic method involves taking estrogen and progestin separately
- with estrogen taken either every day or daily for 25 days of the
month and progestin taken for 10 to 14 days of the month. This may
cause monthly "withdrawal" bleeding.
|
| estrogen
and estrogen/progestin skin patches |
Using this method,
a patch is applied to the skin of the abdomen or buttocks for 3 ½
or 7 days. The patch is then discarded and a new one is applied. The
patch can be left on at all times, even while swimming or bathing,
and either the estrogen, or estrogen/progestin combination is delivered
through the skin into the bloodstream. Progestin can be taken in a
pill form with the patch. The patches may cause monthly bleeding.
|
| estrogen
cream |
Estrogen cream is
inserted into the vagina or used locally around the vulva to help
with vaginal dryness and urinary problems. |
| raloxifene |
Raloxifene is an estrogen-like
drug (sometimes called "designer estrogen") that is part of a new
class of drugs called selective estrogen receptor modulators (SERMs).
|
For women who are appropriate candidates for HRT, this type of therapy
can often be customized to provide the most benefits with the least side
effects. It is important for women to talk with their physician about
any discomfort or menstrual symptoms experienced with HRT, as treatment
approaches and dosages can be adjusted.
|